SCHMITZ LAB AT YALE
  • Home
  • People
    • Os Schmitz
    • Annise Dobson
    • Elizabeth Forbes
    • James Lichtenstein
    • Mary Burak
    • Julia Monk
    • Kristy Ferraro
    • Kaggie Orrick
    • Nathalie Sommer
    • Quint Doan
    • Stan Gosliner
    • Dylan Feldmeier
    • Vivian Hawkinson
    • Janey Lienau
    • Lab Alumni
  • Research
    • Animals & Nutrient Cycling
    • Human-Wildlife Interactions
    • Landscape Spatial Dynamics
    • Species Interactions in Food Webs
    • Invasive Species
  • Blog
  • Pubs
  • Media
  • Join

Hunting with fear: Can humans fill the role of large carnivores?

6/13/2014

32 Comments

 
-- Jennie Miller PhD Candidate
Picture


















Hunting_Cripple Creek Colorado

In suburban neighborhoods across the globe, it is no longer surprising to see deer grazing outside downtown offices in the mid-day sun, brazenly snacking along sidewalks or grazing on gardens as pedestrians pass within petting distance. These animals, once cherished for their shy and flighty nature, now boldly roam among humans and their property, spreading disease and environmental devastation in their wake. Managers have had little success in their attempts to control overabundant ungulates with common methods such as culling and contraceptives, which are also costly and controversial. However, a recent review published in the Journal of Applied Ecology presents a new wildlife management tool that may offer a less bloody and more effective alternative: fear.

Over the past decade, ecologists have found mounting evidence of an idea that horror films have exploited over the last century – that the threat of death is scarier than death itself. Just as countless starlets have cowered from mere threats of torture from dark-hooded movie murders, prey animals make great sacrifices to avoid the simple threat of attack from wild carnivores. Just the presence of predators – be they tarantulas, terns or tigers – can elevate stress levels in their prey that hamper feeding, reproduction and ultimately survival. In essence, predators terrify their prey long before they pounce.

The non-lethal ‘fear effects’ from carnivores can constrain prey populations as strongly as – if not stronger than – actual kills made by carnivores. Yet most management programs aimed at reducing overabundant deer populations have ignored fear effects, instead using methods such as hunting and birth control that rely on mortality alone to control ungulates. In their March 2013 article, Dr. Joris Cromsig and colleagues highlight the importance of incorporating fear effects into ungulate management. Humans should, basically, scare ungulates to death.

Cromsig et al. suggest adapting current practices of hunting to generate greater fear in ungulates. By extending the hunting season and area, hunters could evoke greater and more constant levels of fear in ungulates, creating stress that reduces herd sizes and shifts grazing patterns. But can humans adequately fill the role of large carnivores and limit ungulate populations through fear alone? As a doctoral student who spends hours contemplating how fear affects prey, I found Cromsig et al.’s suggestion intriguing yet in need of additional discussion.

In applying ideas about the ‘ecology of fear’ to practical management, Cromsig and colleagues contribute to an emerging conversation on predation risk as a management tool (for examples see Berger 2007 and Treves et al. 2011). Non-lethal fear effects do appear to have great – and largely unexplored – utility for wildlife management issues such as ungulate overgrazing,
livestock depredation and carnivore conservation. And by infusing fear effects into current practices of hunting implemented in countries worldwide, Cromsig et al. present a technique that could generate drastic changes with minimal cost and effort.
Picture

















Deer_Wodu Media


While the theoretical framework is strong, several limitations offer challenges in implementing the idea of ‘hunting for fear’ as a management tool. For one, ecologists have yet to fully understand how the fear of carnivores varies spatially and temporally, as well as with predator hunting mode, so simulating fear effects in nature would be difficult. Furthermore, because game management involves humans as much as animals, hunters would need to adapt their fear effects uniquely by location to meet both cultural expectations and ecosystem composition. Cromsig and colleagues recognize these challenges and discuss them in their article.

However, several additional issues would be valuable to consider when deciding whether and how to implement ‘hunting for fear’ for ungulate control. First, increasing human activity in natural spaces – even as a management tool – must be scrupulously considered because these efforts could easily result in unintended side effects on the ecosystem. Recreating carnivore fear effects with humans would be most applicable in areas where carnivore populations have been extirpated or reduced to densities where predators no longer generate significant fear effects on prey populations. If predators are still present in the environment (and even if they are not), the presence of humans could strongly disturb the ecosystem, creating more problems than solutions. Most carnivores, as well as numerous other species, are highly sensitive to human presence and spatially and/or temporally avoid human activity, altering their behaviors and roles within the food web. These types of unintended side effects on the ecosystem must be examined carefully prior to implementation to determine whether ‘hunting for fear’ could do more harm than good.

Second, even with a low predator density, encouraging humans to spend more time in wild spaces might inflate human-wildlife conflict in parts of the world. For instance, bringing humans into jungles with low densities of tigers and leopards in an attempt to control their populous prey species (such as wild pigs and nilgai antelope, which are considered some of the worst crop-raiding pests in southeast Asia) could displace big cats from their last remaining habitats, cause them to hunt livestock and/or encourage attacks on people. At the least, increasing the chance of confrontation between humans and large carnivores could likely further amplify negative attitudes towards carnivores that already create challenges for conservation. Thus, ‘hunting for fear’ should likely not be attempted in locations where dangerous large carnivores still exist, even in low densities.

Considering these concerns, it appears that ‘hunting for fear’ might generate the greatest ecological benefits with the fewest negative repercussions on humans and wild species alike in areas where carnivores have been extirpated and ungulate control is desperately needed to restore ecosystem health. Prime examples include the urban areas of many developed countries in Europe and North America, such as the United States where Cromsig et al. point to over-browsing by white-tailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus) as the cause of the extinction of species such as White trillium (Trillium grandiflorum ). In these areas where large carnivores are locally extinct, people could functionally replace the fear effects on prey that carnivores once created when food webs were intact. Indeed, this possibility speaks to the powerful role that humans can play in the ecosystem and illustrates the importance of a new perspective that incorporates humans into food webs, such as human-nature coupling (Liu et al. 2007).

The incorporation of fear into hunting as a management tool requires careful forethought and small-scale experimentation to avoid devastating side effects, such as those that have accompanied the introduction of invasive species to control agricultural pests. I encourage particular forethought prior to the application of ‘hunting for fear’ in countries with poor forest management infrastructure, where hunting may be especially difficult to regulate.

Overall, incorporating fear effects into hunting may offer an innovative technique for controlling ungulate populations. ‘Hunting for fear’ is a prime example of a practical tool that applies principles from species interactions to solve an ecological problem. These types of tools are rare yet essential if science-informed management is to rigorously address the complexities of species and ecosystem conservation.
32 Comments
Nuno link
5/10/2016 09:39:29 pm

It's sad to see all the destruction we humans are causing to our planet's wildlife.

Reply
ball pythons link
8/19/2016 04:21:37 pm

Great information

Reply
Harbor seal link
10/19/2016 10:39:57 pm

I am genuinely thankful to the owner of this website who has shared this fantastic piece of writing at at this place.

Reply
Ar Khan link
2/3/2018 07:46:03 am

i have bees searching for a long time to find out like as post. just i have more benefited from this best idea. thanks

Reply
Helen link
9/3/2018 12:47:08 pm

Lovely update thanks!

Reply
Hunter International Livestock link
9/5/2018 03:24:15 am

Thanks for sharing this with all of us. It is very informative and valuable Source to read and for collecting some knowledge. The Hunter International Livestock is a Fermoy based livestock export company that primarily engaged in the producing, trading and transporting all kinds of livestock within Egypt and abroad.

Reply
John link
10/4/2018 02:48:05 am

This writing is impressive and eye catching as well. I express my thanks and gratitude to the writer and the website for uncovering vital information. It grabbed my attention immediately. Hopefully, we will get to read more of this through similar posts.

Reply
Govt job circular link
11/6/2018 04:05:10 pm

wow, very interesting article.thank you, man.
I respect next time this article is helping others people. thank you.

Reply
tolga erman link
12/15/2018 03:41:21 am

<a href="http://www.kitapbasimfiyatlari.com/" rel="nofollow"><strong>Kitap basım fiyatları</strong>, Kitap basım maliyeti, <strong>Kitap Basim Fiyatlari</strong>, Kitap Basim Maliyeti, <strong>Kitap Fiyatlari</strong>, Baski Fiyati, <strong>Kitap Baski Maliyeti</strong>, Kitap Baski Fiyatlari, <strong>Kitap Yayin Maliyeti</strong>, Kitap Maliyeti, <strong>Kitap Dağıtım</strong>, Kitap Resimleme, <strong>Kitap Basım Maliyeti</strong>, Kitap Fiyatları, <strong>Baskı Fiyatı</strong>, Kitap Baskı Maliyeti, <strong>Kitap Basım Fiyatları</strong>, Kitap Bastırmak İsteyenler, <strong>http://www.kitapbasimfiyatlari.com</strong> </a><span id="ms-rterangepaste-end"></span>

Reply
led fener link
12/18/2018 08:21:01 am

Led fener, Led fener fiyatları, Fener Fiyatları, Fener Maliyeti, Lazer Fiyatları, Yeşil Lazer Fiyatları, Yeşil Lazer Pointer, Lazer Pointer, El feneri, Led El Feneri, Led Lamba, Toptan Led Fener, Toptan Lazer Pointer, Toptan Fener, Şarjlı Lazer, Yeşil Lazer, El feneri Fiyatları, Fener Fiyatları, http://www.ledfener.com

Reply
Kitap Basım Fiyatları link
12/18/2018 08:21:34 am

Kitap basım fiyatları, Kitap basım maliyeti, Kitap Basim Fiyatlari, Kitap Basim Maliyeti, Kitap Fiyatlari, Baski Fiyati, Kitap Baski Maliyeti, Kitap Baski Fiyatlari, Kitap Yayin Maliyeti, Kitap Maliyeti, Kitap Dağıtım, Kitap Resimleme, Kitap Basım Maliyeti, Kitap Fiyatları, Baskı Fiyatı, Kitap Baskı Maliyeti, Kitap Basım Fiyatları, Kitap Bastırmak İsteyenler, http://www.kitapbasimfiyatlari.com 

Reply
paykasa link
4/27/2019 09:05:52 am

paykasa güvenlir hızlı işlem

Reply
Saimon link
5/2/2019 11:19:26 pm

Thanks for sharing this with all of us. It is very informative and valuable Source to read and for collecting some knowledge

Reply
Jenny link
5/3/2019 11:40:37 pm

Thank you. It's very informative article and I found new information I did not know before

Reply
Jennifer link
5/4/2019 11:13:29 am

Your article is very nice and filled with information. Thank you very much for sharing such important information.

Reply
Kyle link
5/20/2019 12:56:52 pm

Thanks. Hope one day you record your lectures for the world to view and benefit from

Reply
Rosy EPS link
7/5/2019 04:09:59 am

Thank you so much for this post as it’s been a great source of inspiration to me. It is really helpful to me. I hope that will connect with your website in near future. Thanks for sharing.

Reply
Zin UCRH link
7/5/2019 04:11:51 am

It is really helpful to me. Thanks for information from this blog. Besides, I will hope to contribute and assist all you like you were help me. Thanks for sharing.

Reply
KylePhan link
7/21/2019 11:17:30 am

The importance of the scientific program after reading this article became very great for me.
Thank you very good

Reply
tolga erman link
10/31/2019 11:33:53 am

<h1 class="title" style="margin-top: 20px; margin-bottom: 10px; font-size: 22px; font-family: Poppins, sans-serif; font-weight: 700; line-height: 28px; color: rgb(206, 27, 40); position: relative; overflow-wrap: break-word;">Pvcpets.com</h1><p style="margin-bottom: 20px; overflow-wrap: break-word; color: rgb(116, 129, 130); font-family: Poppins, sans-serif; font-size: 15px;">Pvc malzeme üretimi yapıyoruz. 80 micron ve 900 micron malzeme üretiyoruz</p><p style="margin-bottom: 20px; overflow-wrap: break-word; color: rgb(116, 129, 130); font-family: Poppins, sans-serif; font-size: 15px;">80 – 150 micron arası Pencereciler ve Dosyacılar</p><p style="margin-bottom: 20px; overflow-wrap: break-word; color: rgb(116, 129, 130); font-family: Poppins, sans-serif; font-size: 15px;">150 micron ve üzeri Termoformcular kullanmakta</p><p style="margin-bottom: 20px; overflow-wrap: break-word; color: rgb(116, 129, 130); font-family: Poppins, sans-serif; font-size: 15px;">Şeffaf ve Renkli bütün çeşitleriden üretim yapıyoruz</p><p style="margin-bottom: 20px; overflow-wrap: break-word; color: rgb(116, 129, 130); font-family: Poppins, sans-serif; font-size: 15px;">Nakliye bize ait</p><p style="margin-bottom: 20px; overflow-wrap: break-word; color: rgb(116, 129, 130); font-family: Poppins, sans-serif; font-size: 15px;">Sipariş sürenizden sonra 10 gün içinde malzemeleriniz teslim ediyoruz.</p><p style="margin-bottom: 20px; overflow-wrap: break-word; color: rgb(116, 129, 130); font-family: Poppins, sans-serif; font-size: 15px;">Teklif ve termin süresi hakkında detaylı bilgi için:</p><p style="margin-bottom: 20px; overflow-wrap: break-word; color: rgb(116, 129, 130); font-family: Poppins, sans-serif; font-size: 15px;"><strong style="color: rgb(33, 33, 33); font-size: 24px;"><a href="https://www.pvcpets.com/" style="color: rgb(206, 27, 40);"><span style="font-size: 12px;">Pvc, Mono Pvc, Pvc – Pe, Pvc – Pepeelable, Pvc / Pe / Evoh / Pe,</span></a></strong><br></p><h4 style="font-family: Poppins, sans-serif; line-height: 25px; color: rgb(33, 33, 33); margin-top: 10px; margin-bottom: 10px; font-size: 24px;"><a href="https://www.pvcpets.com/" style="color: rgb(206, 27, 40);"><span style="font-size: 12px;">Pet, Mono Pet, </span></a><strong><a href="https://www.pvcpets.com/" style="color: rgb(206, 27, 40);"><span style="font-size: 12px;">Pet / Pe, </span></a></strong><a href="https://www.pvcpets.com/" style="color: rgb(206, 27, 40);"></a><strong><a href="https://www.pvcpets.com/" style="color: rgb(206, 27, 40);"><span style="font-size: 12px;">Pet / Pe Peelable</span></a></strong><a href="https://www.pvcpets.com/" style="color: rgb(206, 27, 40);"><span style="font-size: 12px;">, Pet / Pe / Evoh / Pe, Vakum – Termoform, Termoform Ambalaj, Vakum Ambalaj, Plastik Ambalajlar, Endüstriye göre plastik ambalajlar, Ev ve Kimyasal Ambalajlar, Kişisel Bakım ve Kozmetik Ambalajları, Paketlenmiş Tüketici Malları, Sağlık ve İlaç Ambalajı, Yiyecek ve İçecek Paketleme, Ambalaj Çeşitleri, Düşük Yoğunluklu Polietilen (LDPE)</span></a><strong><a href="https://www.pvcpets.com/" style="color: rgb(206, 27, 40);"><span style="font-size: 12px;"> </span></a></strong><a href="https://www.pvcpets.com/" style="color: rgb(206, 27, 40);"><span style="font-size: 12px;">, Polietilen Tereftalat (PET, PETE) , Polipropilen (PP) , Polisitren , Polivinil Klorür (PVC, Vinil) , Yüksek Yoğunluklu Polietilen (HDPE)</span></a></h4>

Reply
tolga erman link
10/31/2019 11:34:56 am

Pvcpets.com
Pvc malzeme üretimi yapıyoruz. 80 micron ve 900 micron malzeme üretiyoruz
80 – 150 micron arası Pencereciler ve Dosyacılar
150 micron ve üzeri Termoformcular kullanmakta
Şeffaf ve Renkli bütün çeşitleriden üretim yapıyoruz
Nakliye bize ait
Sipariş sürenizden sonra 10 gün içinde malzemeleriniz teslim =
ediyoruz.
Teklif ve termin süresi hakkında detaylı bilgi için:
Pvc, Mono Pvc, Pvc – Pe, Pvc – Pepeelable, Pvc / Pe / Evoh / Pe,
Pet, Mono Pet, Pet / Pe, Pet / Pe Peelable, Pet / Pe / Evoh / Pe, Vakum – Termoform, Termoform Ambalaj, Vakum Ambalaj, Plastik Ambalajlar, Endüstriye göre plastik ambalajlar, Ev ve Kimyasal Ambalajlar, Kişisel Bakım ve Kozmetik Ambalajları, Paketlenmiş Tüketici Malları, Sağlık ve İlaç Ambalajı, Yiyecek ve İçecek Paketleme, Ambalaj Çeşitleri, Düşük Yoğunluklu Polietilen (LDPE) , Polietilen Tereftalat (PET, PETE) , Polipropilen (PP) , Polisitren , Polivinil Klorür (PVC, Vinil) , Yüksek Yoğunluklu Polietilen (HDPE)

Reply
led fener link
11/16/2019 02:03:35 am

ledfener.com,
Led fener, ledfener, lazer, lazer pointer, lazerpointer, laser, laser pointer, laserpointer, fener, toptan fener, toptan lazer, toptan lazer pointer, toptan laser, toptan laser pointer, El feneri, Toptan el feneri, toptan fener, wholesale flashlight, wholesale laser, wholesale lazer, fener lamba, fener, toptan el feneri, ledfener.com web sitemizde satışı yapılmaktadır. Toptan El Feneri, Toptan Lazer Pointer, Toptan Lazer, Toptan, Toptan Fener, toptan lazer pointer, toptan laser pointer satışı yapmaktayız.
https://www.ledfener.com/
sitemize bekleriz.

Reply
Spoiler Foiler link
2/15/2020 11:11:46 am

Thank you for a wonderful article. You were provide is very useful information for our

Reply
Bernadette link
6/1/2020 12:33:30 am

I like the post. It really helpful for hunting. This grate blog. Thank you for sharing this post.

Reply
Product reviews link
7/3/2020 06:58:40 am

Thank you for sharing your thoughts with us.
I personally find it very useful. Will share.

Thank you!

Reply
Ryan link
11/12/2020 10:08:08 am

I like your post

Reply
https://nadireser.net/ link
5/2/2021 12:51:18 pm

https://nadireser.net Sahaf, İkinci el kitap satış sitesi.

Reply
Pvcpets.com link
6/26/2021 05:05:16 am

Pvcpets.com sitemizde Pvc, Pet, Pvc rulo, Pet rulo, Pvc levha, Pet levha ürünleri satışı yapılmaktadır.
Mono Pvc
PVC / PE ( Polietilen Lamineli PVC Folyo )
PVC / PE Peelable ( Soyulabilen Polietilen Lamineli PVC Folyo )
PVC / PE / EVOH / PE ( Polietilen / EVOH bariyeri / Polietilen Lamineli PVC Folyo )
PVC / PE / EVOH / Peelable PE ( Polietilen / EVOH bariyeri / Kolay Soyulabilen Polietilen Lamineli PVC Folyo )
Mono PET
PET / PE ( Polietilen Lamineli PET Folyo )
PET / PE / EVOH / PE (Polietilen / EVOH bariyeri / Polietilen Lamineli PET Folyo)
PVC / PE Peelable ( Soyulabilen Polietilen Lamineli PVC Folyo )
PET / PE / EVOH / PE ( Polietilen / EVOH bariyeri / Peelable Polietilen Lamineli PET Folyo )
Satışı yapılmaktadır. Pvcpets.com

Reply
pvcpets.com link
6/26/2021 05:05:59 am

<a href="https://www.pvcpets.com/">Pvcpets.com</a> sitemizde <a href="https://www.pvcpets.com/">Pvc</a>, <a href="https://www.pvcpets.com/">Pet</a>, <a href="https://www.pvcpets.com/">Pvc rulo</a>, <a href="https://www.pvcpets.com/">Pet rulo</a>, <a href="https://www.pvcpets.com/">Pvc levha</a>, <a href="https://www.pvcpets.com/">Pet levha ürünleri</a> satışı yapılmaktadır.
<a href="https://www.pvcpets.com/">Mono Pvc</a>
<a href="https://www.pvcpets.com/">PVC / PE</a> ( Polietilen Lamineli PVC Folyo )
<a href="https://www.pvcpets.com/">PVC / PE Peelable</a> ( Soyulabilen Polietilen Lamineli PVC Folyo )
<a href="https://www.pvcpets.com/">PVC / PE / EVOH / PE</a> ( Polietilen / EVOH bariyeri / Polietilen Lamineli PVC Folyo )
<a href="https://www.pvcpets.com/">PVC / PE / EVOH / Peelable PE</a> ( Polietilen / EVOH bariyeri / Kolay Soyulabilen Polietilen Lamineli PVC Folyo )
<a href="https://www.pvcpets.com/">Mono PET</a>
<a href="https://www.pvcpets.com/">PET / PE</a> ( Polietilen Lamineli PET Folyo )
<a href="https://www.pvcpets.com/">PET / PE / EVOH / PE</a> (Polietilen / EVOH bariyeri / Polietilen Lamineli PET Folyo)
<a href="https://www.pvcpets.com/">PVC / PE Peelable</a> ( Soyulabilen Polietilen Lamineli PVC Folyo )
<a href="https://www.pvcpets.com/">PET / PE / EVOH / PE</a> ( Polietilen / EVOH bariyeri / Peelable Polietilen Lamineli PET Folyo )
Satışı yapılmaktadır. <a href="https://www.pvcpets.com/">Pvcpets.com</a>

Reply
nadireser.net link
7/1/2021 08:22:33 am

https://nadireser.net Sahaf, İkinci el kitap, 2. el kitap, ucuz kitap, Ucuz Kitap Al, nadir kitap, sahaflar çarşısı, kitap sahaf, sahaf kitap, sahaflar, online sahaf, ikinci el kitap sat, ikinci el kitap al, antika kitap, kitap, Kitap satış sitesi, Kütüphane, Kütüphane satışı, Kitap Satışı, Kitap Kiralama, ikinci el kitap satışı, Sahaf kitaplarının satışını yapmakta. https://nadireser.net/

Reply
MckimmeCue link
3/29/2022 09:02:16 am

Excellent article! Your post is essential today. Thanks for sharing, by the way. If you are looking for coupon codes and deals just visit coupon plus deals dot com

Reply
Facboook link
5/29/2022 07:32:11 am

I have to convey my respect for your kindness for all those that require guidance on this one field. Your special commitment to passing the solution up and down has been incredibly functional and has continually empowered most people just like me to achieve their dreams. Your amazing insightful information entails much to me and especially to my peers. Thanks a ton; from all of us.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Archives

    November 2019
    April 2018
    August 2017
    July 2017
    February 2017
    December 2016
    February 2016
    October 2015
    September 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013

    Categories

    All
    Animal Movement
    Energy
    Field Stories
    Human Wildlife Conflict
    Human-wildlife Conflict
    Large Carnivores
    Plant Herbivore
    Plant-herbivore


    Tweets by @SchmitzLab

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Home
  • People
    • Os Schmitz
    • Annise Dobson
    • Elizabeth Forbes
    • James Lichtenstein
    • Mary Burak
    • Julia Monk
    • Kristy Ferraro
    • Kaggie Orrick
    • Nathalie Sommer
    • Quint Doan
    • Stan Gosliner
    • Dylan Feldmeier
    • Vivian Hawkinson
    • Janey Lienau
    • Lab Alumni
  • Research
    • Animals & Nutrient Cycling
    • Human-Wildlife Interactions
    • Landscape Spatial Dynamics
    • Species Interactions in Food Webs
    • Invasive Species
  • Blog
  • Pubs
  • Media
  • Join